BPA Baby Bottle Scare: Fear is Taking Over Society, Says Mom

Spiked Online, the spunky, skeptical British publication dedicated, in its own words, to “waging a culture war of words against misanthropy, priggishness, prejudice, luddism, illiberalism and irrationalism in all their ancient and modern forms” has a go at the mushrooming paranoia over Bisphenol A, or BPA (for short).

In The Great American Baby Bottle Scare, New York writer Nancy McDermott, a mother of two, laments the the way the media, environmental activists and the public have succumbed to a hermeneutic of suspicion that works against the very foundational principle of rational thought: pro and contra reasoning:

When scientists find nothing in claims about BPA, for instance, it is dismissed as the product of chemical industry manipulation rather than genuine and profound weaknesses with the entire thesis. Large, well-designed studies conducted by independently audited contract labs are suspect because they are ‘industry funded’. Apparently even Harvard University’s Center for Risk Assessment is merely a shill for the chemical industry because their 2000 report on BPA was commissioned by the American Plastics Council. In fact, anyone who dares to be critical of the BPA scare is accused of using the tobacco industry’s ‘delaying tactics’.

Most problematically, some now call for ‘independent science’, untainted by any ties to industry. The term is deceptive. Science is science. It stands or falls on its own merits. The notion of ‘independent science’ trivialises the whole notion of objectivity and betrays contempt for the individual men and women involved in scientific research, both in terms of the way they conduct their own work and in the way they review the work of others.

The problem with the BPA scare is not just that individual parents have been frightened out of their wits about a basically benign chemical, or even the potentially huge cost of identifying alternatives and scrapping entirely safe and effective manufacturing processes. The real problem with the BPA scare is the way it elevates fear above dispassionate consideration of the evidence, and makes it into an organising principle for all of society.

In other words, politicians, journalists and activists have created a narrative for legislative action on BPA that mimics the Bush administration’s narrative for action on WMDs in Iraq, otherwise known as the one-percent doctrine: if you think there might be any chance of a risk, then there is a risk, therefore action is warranted. Suspicion, therefore, and not evidence, is the criterion for action.

One Response to BPA Baby Bottle Scare: Fear is Taking Over Society, Says Mom

  1. Bob Herrick says:

    I was commissioned to do a risk assessment of BPA late last year. One insight that I developed is that the NTP, which relies heavily on the findings of Expert Panels, has more or less fixed a scale that calibrates how it reports findings. That scale ranges from ‘minimal concern’ and ‘negligible concern’ at the low end to ‘serious concern’ at the high end. It is interesting that none of the possible characterizations can be expressed without including the word ‘concern.’ The press sees the phrase ‘some concern’ and imputes a meaning to that phrase that is not necessarily in line with how the EP or the NTP uses the phrase. I have not read more than a few EP reports and their associated NTP findings, but of those that I have read, other than ‘insufficient information’ EVERY one has had some modified form of the word concern. Perhaps either some calibration could be expressed by NTP or they might consider a differnt set of words.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 38 other followers